Jun 11, 2009 6
Old School, New School, Middle School. Who Cares?
I don’t get it. I really don’t.
You can shout as loud as you want about loving or hating a particular edition of a game all you want. The louder you shout the less likely I am to listen to you though. Try and tell me that the way I play my games doesn’t fit into your idea of an RPG and it’s a guaranteed way to get me to ignore you.
So why is it I’m getting sucked into the old school revival fights. I’m not commenting on anyone’s blog supporting one view or another and I’m not getting involved in any threads on the various forums. But at the end of the day it’s still having an effect on me. I see fellow bloggers wanting to give up because it’s just not worth it and others gaining a form of celebratory status because they can type louder than anyone else.
I’ve been playing RPG’s for over 20 years. I’ve ran the entire gamut of games from the original version of D&D right through Rolemaster, MechWarrior, Twilight 2000 to the Storyteller systems. I’ve played in games where the story is the main thing and didn’t roll a dice in months. I’ve played in games where we’ve took 20 hours of gameplay to clear the smallest of dungeons thanks to random encounters and really bad player created maps meaning it takes us forever to escape. Whenever someone tries to define what old school or new school is I sit and tick off most of the points that apply to myself. I sit firmly in the middle and get the best of both worlds as and when I want to play a certain kind of game.
If you want to call yourself a Grognard then go ahead. Personally I’m just a person that’s happy to play OD&D if that is the system that best suits the game we want to play. I play AD&D because I have all the books and know the rules. If I could afford all the books I’d need for 4e I’d probably play that as well.
I guess what I’m saying is I’m fed up with folk shoving their opinions down my throat when at the end of the day it’s a game we’re playing and it’s supposed to be about fun. If your idea of fun isn’t the same as mine then feel free to leave and go play your game elsewhere and shut the hell up. In other words…enjoy what you play and how you play it. We have such a diverse range of games these days that there is something for everyone. Stop trying to pigeonhole them and get stuck in to the game.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!












